About Me

Name: Randy
Biography
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Archives

Blog Roll

 

McCain's Underdog, "Rudy" Campaign

Anyone watching the McCain campaign over the last year and a half has to admire the sheer grit of it. First he staked his entire candidacy on the success of the surge at a time when Iraq seemed on the verge of civil war and the United States was suffering over 100 combat deaths a month. The surge now appears to have succeeded. Next, in August of 2007, when his campaign looked all but dead in the water, he chopped his staff back to bare bones, replacing some key players, and of those who remained many worked for free. Together they rebuilt the campaign, and through events not entirely of their making, McCain prevailed in the Republican primary. Then he faced the prospect of a general election campaign against Barack Obama with strong head winds running against anyone from Republican Party. Obama was consistently running ahead of him in the polls, then came the most surprising and gutsy move of his campaign yet. McCain made the announcement and then the fanfare theme music (trumpets and French horns blarring) from the movie “Rudy” played as out strode Governor Sarah Palin. More appropriate music could not have been chosen for a the occasion and the campaign as a whole.

Rudy is based on the true story of the never-say-quit Dan Ruettiger. As a young man with mediocre grades from a working class family, he had no business thinking he could get into Notre Dame, but through much perseverance and a few years later than most, he did; as someone 5’6" tall, 165 lbs, he had no business trying out for the Notre Dame football, but he did; he had no business thinking he would make it as a walk on to the Notre Dame football team (a team always in contention for the national title during the years Rudy attended), but he did; he had no business thinking he would ever be able to suit up for a game, but he did. He had no business thinking he would get in the game, and…then comes the critical moment in the story. It’s been close the entire last home game of the season against Georgia Tech, Rudy’s last chance to play. Finally Notre Dame scores, running an interception in for a touchdown, making it 17-3. The Fighting Irish then recover a fumble with less than a minute to go. 

Everything that is conventional says the Notre Dame quarterback should take a knee and run the clock out: that was the play coach Dan Devine called. The players realize if they follow that course, Rudy, who has spent the last two seasons earning their respect playing defense against them in practice, would not get in the game. The Notre Dame players on the sidelines begin to lead the crowd chanting “Rudy, Rudy, Rudy…” The players on the field decide to overrule their coach and risk everything. The call, “A halfback pass to the right, going for the endzone. A riskier choice could not have been called.  If Tech intercepts the ball and runs it in for a touchdown, they could  potentially go on to win the game. “Hike”, the Rudy fanfare music (that Sarah Palin came on stage to) begins to play as the quarterback fades back and the wide receivers sprint down the field; he pitches to the halfback who starts to run the ball. Coach Devine, watching the play unfold, yells out, “What the hell is he doing!?” The halfback then pulls up and passes toward the endzone, Touchdown!! The team and the crowd go wild and keep chanting, “Rudy, Rudy, Rudy…” Coach Devine relents letting Rudy go in to the game with 27 seconds left to play. 

Now Rudy is on the field for the kickoff.  He runs downs the field, but doesn’t get in on the action. One play left.  Georgia Tech's quarterback fades back. Rudy gets through the offensive line, chases the quarterback down and drops him for a sack. The fans go wild. The theme music plays in the background as Rudy gets carried off the field.   

John McCain, by choosing Sarah Palin, made that halfback pass to the right (Notre Dame means Our Lady by-the-way).  Now, particularly after the Katie Couric interview, some are beginning to doubt if she has what it takes to be on the national stage.  Everything that was conventional said McCain should have chosen someone like Governor Mitt Romney or Tim Pawlenty—both are conservative (though Romney lacks the confidence of social conservatives and Pawlenty is not well known nationally) who fit the bill for a Vice Presidential pick: that is they should do no harm and perhaps help with a certain demographic or in a swing state. If McCain had chosen one of these men (or the others on his short list), the Republican Party (like Rudy) would not have been able to get in the game and Obama in all likelihood would have stayed ahead in the polls and went on for the win. Now, though the polls are trending a bit towards Obama this last week or so, it’s still anybody’s game. Perhaps Palin will be able to really get back in the mix this week, and drop the Democrats’ backup quarterback for a sack Thursday during the Vice Presidential debates. Regardless McCain has shown time-and-again,despite being slightly outmatched by events and in dollars, he’s playing to win. That never-say-quit, underdog spirit (probably born at least in part during his years surviving in captivity) is to be admired and hopefully will result in him and Palin being carried from the field in victory. 
 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Randall DeSoto is the author of the book We Hold These Truths about how leaders have appealed to beliefs found in the Declaration of Independence throughout our nation's history. 
Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

Obama and Other People's Words

Barack Obama has a penchant to borrow the words of others and pass them off as his own.  Three blatant examples of this, including from the movie The American President, make the point very well.  The most publicized one occurred during the primary season this past spring when he co-opted a rift from Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick's inaugural address during which he said, 'We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal' -- just words. Just words. 'We have nothing to fear but fear itself' -- just words. 'Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country' -- just words. 'I have a dream' -- just words."  Obama changed Patrick's order and dropped the JFK reference: "'I have a dream.' Just words. 'We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.' Just words. 'We have nothing to fear but fear itself.' Just words, just speeches!"  The media called him on it, and Obama really did not have a good excuse except to say he and Gov. Patrick are friends and trade ideas all the time. 
A few weeks ago, Obama was caught again borrowing someone else's words without attribution.  This time rather than taking from a person's actual spoken words, he chose a political cartoon character.  A cartoon by Tom Toles, which appeared in the Washington Post earlier this month, had McCain (with Governor Palin to his side) saying, “Watch out, Mr. Bush! With the exception of economic policy and energy policy and social issues and tax policy and foreign policy and Supreme Court appointments and Rove-style politics, we’re coming in there to shake things up!”  Obama again changed the order slightly and passed the rift off as his own.  "Watch out, George Bush -- except for economic policy, healthcare policy, tax policy, education policy, foreign policy and Karl Rove-style politics, we're really going to shake things up in Washington."  Nearly word-for-word. 
 

Not as well publicized was Obama's apparent use of phrasings from the movie The American President during his Democratic Nomination acceptance speech extravaganza at Denver's Invesco Field.  In the movie, President Andrew Shepherd (played by Michael Douglas) attacks his conservative opponent Bob Rumson (Richard Dreyfus) in a climatic monologue near the end of the movie saying, “I was operating under the assumption…that he simply didn’t get it…Bob’s problem isn’t that he does not get it.  Bob’s problem is that he can’t sell it.”  Obama decided his opponent really doesn’t get it: “It’s not because John McCain doesn’t care.  It’s because John McCain just doesn’t get it.”  During that same monologue in the movie, Shepherd calls out Rumson to a debate on specific issues saying, “If you want to talk about character and American values, fine.  Just tell me when and where and I’ll show up.”  Obama did the same thing: “If John McCain wants to have a debate about who has the temperament, and judgment, to serve as the next commander-in-chief, that’s a debate I’m ready to have.”     

Near the end of his acceptance speech, Obama again appeared to draw from the movie.  President Shepherd says in the same monologue quoted above that being "...American isn’t easy” and added further into his remarks, “We have serious problems to solve and we need serious men to solve them.  I promise you whatever your problem is, Bob Rumson is not the least bit interested in solving it.  He’s interested in two things and two things only:  Making you afraid of it and telling you who is to blame for it.  That’s how you win elections…” appealing to earlier and easier times and talking about “family and American values and personal character.”  Obama’s version, “America, our work will not be easy.  The challenges we face require tough choices…They claim that our insistence on something larger, something firmer…is just a Trojan Horse for higher taxes and abandonment of traditional values.  And that is to be expected.  Because if you don’t have any fresh ideas, then you use stale tactics to scare voters…You make a big election about small things.  And you know what – it’s worked before.” 

Obama went right down the checklist of the imaginary President Shepherd: 1) America, we face serious problems (implied: that only the federal government can solve for you with new programs and spending)--Check.  2) Conservatives don’t want to solve your problems--Check.  3) They only want to scare and manipulate you with appeals to traditional values--Check.  Note, apparently the “small things” Obama is referring to are among others, abortion and how we define marriage and family, since these appear in the preceding paragraph in his speech.   

President Shepherd ends his monologue with one of the great lines from the movie saying emphatically to his would-be replacement Rumson, “My name’s Andrew Shepherd and I am the President.”  For a split second you believe that he is, or that he could be.  Michael Douglas, when asked in light of how Presidential he looked playing the part, would he ever consider running for public office, quickly responded, "No."  He observed there is a big difference between playing the President and being able to deliver someone else's words before a camera on queue and actually being the President.  The same observation holds true when choosing who will be our next President this November. 
 
 
Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive
« Previous1Next »